Effect of sharia-based nursing care using swanson's caring model (ShariaSwanCare) on patient satisfaction: a quasi-experimental study
Dublin Core
Title
Effect of sharia-based nursing care using swanson's caring model (ShariaSwanCare) on patient satisfaction: a quasi-experimental study
Subject
islamic hospitals, nursing care quality, patient satisfaction, sharia-based nursing care, swanson caring
model
model
Description
Introduction: Patient satisfaction is a key indicator of healthcare quality. As of 2023, Indonesia is home to 74 certified
Sharia-based hospitals. However, research examining the effects of Sharia-based nursing care on patient satisfaction
remains limited. Existing studies often treat Islamic healthcare practices and caring theories as separate domains,
lacking integrated analysis through structured frameworks such as Swanson’s Caring Theory. This study aimed to
evaluate the effect of Sharia-Based Nursing Care, utilizing Swanson’s Caring Model (ShariaSwanCare), on patient
satisfaction in hospital settings.
Methods: A quasi-experimental pretest–posttest design with a control group was employed, involving 76 hospitalized
patients (38 per group) selected via purposive sampling. Participants received a structured, five-day treatment for
conditions such as hypertension, diabetes mellitus, cerebrovascular accident (stroke), and pneumonia. Eligibility
criteria included compos mentis status and uninterrupted completion of the five-day treatment period. Patients who
were transferred to other wards were excluded. The intervention group received ShariaSwanCare, administered daily
for five consecutive days, with patient satisfaction assessed every 24 hours. The control group received standard hospital
care without additional interventions. Data were analyzed using both paired t-tests and independent t-tests. A
significance level of p < 0.05 was used for all analyses.
Results: Statistical analysis yielded a p-value of < 0.001, indicating that the implementation of ShariaSwanCare had a
significant positive effect on patient satisfaction. Specifically, patients in the intervention group showed a greater
increase in satisfaction scores compared to the control group. The paired t-test revealed a significant improvement from
pre- to post-intervention in both groups, but the effect was more pronounced in the intervention group.
Conclusions: Sharia-based nursing practices, when integrated with Swanson’s Caring Model, can effectively enhance
patient satisfaction. With appropriate training and structured implementation, these practices have the potential to be
adopted across Islamic hospitals.
Sharia-based hospitals. However, research examining the effects of Sharia-based nursing care on patient satisfaction
remains limited. Existing studies often treat Islamic healthcare practices and caring theories as separate domains,
lacking integrated analysis through structured frameworks such as Swanson’s Caring Theory. This study aimed to
evaluate the effect of Sharia-Based Nursing Care, utilizing Swanson’s Caring Model (ShariaSwanCare), on patient
satisfaction in hospital settings.
Methods: A quasi-experimental pretest–posttest design with a control group was employed, involving 76 hospitalized
patients (38 per group) selected via purposive sampling. Participants received a structured, five-day treatment for
conditions such as hypertension, diabetes mellitus, cerebrovascular accident (stroke), and pneumonia. Eligibility
criteria included compos mentis status and uninterrupted completion of the five-day treatment period. Patients who
were transferred to other wards were excluded. The intervention group received ShariaSwanCare, administered daily
for five consecutive days, with patient satisfaction assessed every 24 hours. The control group received standard hospital
care without additional interventions. Data were analyzed using both paired t-tests and independent t-tests. A
significance level of p < 0.05 was used for all analyses.
Results: Statistical analysis yielded a p-value of < 0.001, indicating that the implementation of ShariaSwanCare had a
significant positive effect on patient satisfaction. Specifically, patients in the intervention group showed a greater
increase in satisfaction scores compared to the control group. The paired t-test revealed a significant improvement from
pre- to post-intervention in both groups, but the effect was more pronounced in the intervention group.
Conclusions: Sharia-based nursing practices, when integrated with Swanson’s Caring Model, can effectively enhance
patient satisfaction. With appropriate training and structured implementation, these practices have the potential to be
adopted across Islamic hospitals.
Creator
Muhammad Hadi1
* , Sri Mulyani1
, Tang Li Yoong2
, Eni Widiastuti1
, Rini Fatma Kartika3
,
and Idyatul Hasanah4
* , Sri Mulyani1
, Tang Li Yoong2
, Eni Widiastuti1
, Rini Fatma Kartika3
,
and Idyatul Hasanah4
Source
http://dx.doi.org/10.20473/jn.v20i3.71631
Date
3 August 2025
Contributor
peri irawan
Format
pdf
Language
english
Type
text
Files
Collection
Citation
Muhammad Hadi1
* , Sri Mulyani1
, Tang Li Yoong2
, Eni Widiastuti1
, Rini Fatma Kartika3
,
and Idyatul Hasanah4, “Effect of sharia-based nursing care using swanson's caring model (ShariaSwanCare) on patient satisfaction: a quasi-experimental study,” Repository Horizon University Indonesia, accessed February 21, 2026, https://repository.horizon.ac.id/items/show/11154.